John Senior and the Restoration of Realism

Made for the Stars but Rooted in the Soil

by Fr. Francis Bethel, O.S.B.
reviewed by Erin Doom & Eighth Day Books

Feast of the Holy Nun and Martyr Pelagia of Tarsus
Anno Domini 2020, May 4


John Senior and the Restoration of Realism by Father Francis Bethel, O.S.B.

This is our kind of book. And we agree with Alice von Hildebrand’s foreword, which claims that it “should be in the hands of every educator and every parent.” We’d add that it ought to be in the hands of anybody and everybody who cares about culture, be they carpenter or attorney, computer geek or luddite. This is the story of a seed that was planted at the University of Kansas in the 1970s: the Pearson Integrated Humanities Program (“IHP”). According to Fr. Bethel, the program was built on the tenet that reality is real, a “revolutionary” fact for modernity, which was communicated in IHP through the prose, poetry, music, architecture and art of Western culture, in conjunction with the book of Nature. This seed seemed to have been squashed when the program was shut down by the state, due to “controversial” conversions to the Catholic faith and young men being “brainwashed” into exploring the Christian vocation of monasticism. Despite the state’s attempt to destroy this seed, however, that group of young men went on to become monks at the French medieval Benedictine Abbey of Notre-Dame de Fontgombault. In 1999, those same monks moved back to the U.S., near Tulsa, OK, where the original seed blossomed into a new full-blown monastic community: Our Lady of Clear Creek Abbey. Almost two decades later, that abbey has grown into the heart of a growing community of lay people who participate in the monastery’s thriving liturgical life. That seed has also blossomed in many other ways, including the creation of schools inspired by its curriculum (including Eighth Day Institute’s vision for a catechetical Academy), and the publication of the delightful novel and international bestseller The Awakening of Miss Prim, which can be read as an imaginative portrayal of IHP in action. But Fr. Bethel’s book is much more than the story of a blossoming seed, and certainly more than a mere biography of John Senior, the primary catalyst for IHP. It might be better considered a study of John Senior’s thought, which Fr. Bethel summarizes as Senior’s realization that in order for humans to fulfill their vocation of tending toward and shining like the stars, they must be nourished in the real soil of this world, that “we must ground all intellectual and affective life on the experiential and imaginative level.” Realism was the primary key to Senior’s mature thought and the guiding principle for his development of IHP. And it’s best articulated in the title of this book’s introduction: “Made for the Stars but Rooted in the Soil.” John Senior’s life and work remind us of what we’re made for and where we come from. And Fr. Bethel’s book is a testament to and inspiration for that vocation. It really ought to be in everyone’s hands, including yours.

452 pp. cloth $49.99
Members (Patrons+) receive 10% discount, plus many other perks!

Exercise the virtue of patience, resist Amazon, and support Eighth Day Books. Give them a call at 1.800.841.2541 between 10 am and 8 pm CST Mon-Sat and engage in a conversation about books and ideas with a live human person who reads books and loves to discuss them. Or, if you insist, visit their website at www.eighthdaybooks.com.

Share this Post on Your Preferred Platform

By Jeremy Wagner May 15, 2026
An Ode to St. Brendan the Voyager
By Luke Taylor Gilstrap May 11, 2026
Materialism vs. Liturgical Life
By Fr. Mark Sultani May 1, 2026
The Faith of the Holy Myrrhbearing Women
By Mark Watney April 29, 2026
Oxymorons and the Cross 
By Michael Simmon April 16, 2026
Warrior, Shepherd, Penitent, and Type of Christ
By Luke Taylor Gilstrap April 15, 2026
The Church in the World
By Luke Taylor Gilstrap April 10, 2026
A reflection for Orthodox Great and Holy Friday
By Luke Taylor Gilstrap April 3, 2026
A reflection for Good Friday
By Luke Taylor Gilstrap March 20, 2026
The Character of the Early Church
By Michael Simmon February 11, 2026
The Sisters of Sophia will gather on the Commemoration of the Great Martyr Theodore, Anno Domini 2026, February 17. Rachel Garton will present The Battlefield of Compassion: Florence Nightingale, Clara Barton, and St Verena . Sisters of Sophia When Every third Tuesday Where The Ladder 2836 E Douglas, Wichita Parking available behind Eighth Day Books Schedule Food, drink, and fellowship at 6:30pm Eighth Day Convocation & Lecture at 7:20pm Membership Required? No, but do consider joining the community! Learn more and join here !
More Posts