1. Essays et al: "Early Christian Mission: An Applied Theology of Patience"
On Jan. 17, in the year of our Lord 2014, Alan Kreider presented a magnificent lecture at the fifth annual Eighth Day Symposium on “Constantine and the Transformation of Patience.” Here is the opening two paragraphs of the lecture:
Patience, we are told, is a virtue. And over the years, as I have read early Christian authors, I have often encountered the words for patience (patientia, hupomone, makrothumia) recurring in their writings. But it was not until I read Robert Wilken’s The Spirit of Early Christian Thought
that I found a serious treatment of the theme of patience. Wilken not only persuaded me that patience was important to the patristic writers; he also helped me see that patience could be an overarching perspective from which to view the early Church’s missional growth. Partly as a result of his writing, patience has become the leitmotif of my forthcoming book Patient Ferment: The Growth of the Church in the Roman Empire.
According to Wilken, patience was “not considered a virtue by the ancients.” But it was the first virtue that a Christian wrote an entire treatise about. Around 200 AD Tertullian wrote On Patience. Fifty years later, Bishop Cyprian of Carthage followed with a second treatise, On the Good of Patience. In the early fourth century, the philosopher Lactantius made patience a central theme in his writing. Finally, a century later after Lactantius, in 417 the great Augustine added a third treatise, once again entitled On Patience. Wilken has convinced me of the special qualities of patience. As he emphasizes, patience is rooted in hope. It is “grounded in the Resurrection. It is life oriented toward a future that is God’s doing . . . [Tertullian], by introducing his readers to a virtue that was modeled on the biblical portrayal of God’s relation to the world and to human beings, . . . redefined what it means to be ‘like God.’”
The rest of his introduction, in good Eighth Day fashion, highlights eight characteristics of early Christian mission, including this third one:
The Church was growing despite the fact that it didn’t seem to think about growth. To contemporaries its growth was a mystery. As Origen put it, growth was an expression of the work of God. So the growth of the church was not in their control. The early Christians didn’t make it a high priority to promote the church’s growth. They didn’t do things that might strike today’s Christians as smart to do: they didn’t have mission programs, decades of evangelism, campaigns based on the Great Commission. After the first century they had almost no missionaries whose names we know. And the early Christians wrote no manuals of missionary techniques or treatises on the virtues of courage or boldness; instead they wrote church orders and treatises on the virtue of patience. In all this, the early Christians were patient. They didn’t seem worried about evangelistic success; they believed that if they lived the gospel faithfully and died well, God would attract to the churches the people that God was saving.
Sounds like Fr. Stephen in yesterday’s post on “The Violence of Modernity.”
2. Books & Culture: Patience with God
by Tomáš Halík
I plan to write a short review of this most excellent book, after I’ve finished reading it. For now, let me just offer you three teasers from the Introduction and the first chapter:
- Patience is what I consider to be the main difference between faith and atheism. What atheism, religious fundamentalism, and the enthusiasm of a too-facile faith have in common is how quickly they can ride roughshod over the mystery we call God … One must never consider mystery ‘over and done with.’ Mystery, unlike a mere dilemma, cannot be overcome; one must wait patiently at its threshold and persevere in it—must carry it in one’s heart—just as Jesus’s mother did according to the Gospel, and allow it to mature there and lead one in turn to maturity.
- When after the fall of Communism, Christ’s followers came out freely into the open after so many years, they noticed many people who applauded them and maybe a few who had previously shaken their fists at them. What they didn’t notice, however, was that the trees all around them were full of Zacchaeuses—those who were unwilling or unable to join the throng of old or brand-new believers, but were neither indifferent nor hostile to them. Those Zacchaeuses were curious seekers, but at the same time they wanted to maintain a certain distance. That odd combination of inquisitiveness and expectation, interest and shyness, and sometimes, maybe, even a feeling of guilt and ‘inadequacy,’ kept them hidden in their fig trees. // By addressing Zacchaeus by name, Jesus emboldened him to come down from his hiding place. He surprised him by wanting to stay in his house even though He risked immediate slander and criticism: ‘He’s accepted the hospitality of a sinner!’ // There is no written account of Zacchaeus’s ever having joined Jesus’s disciples, nor of his having followed Jesus on His travels like the chosen twelve or the throng of other men and women. What we do know, however, is that he decided to change his life, and salvation came to his house. In our times, the Church has been incapable of addressing its Zacchaeuses in like manner.
- I once saw on the wall of a Prague subway station the inscription ‘Jesus is the answer,’ probably written by someone on the way back from some high-spirited evangelistic gathering. Yet someone else had aptly added the words: ‘But what was the question?’ It reminded me of the comment made by the philosopher Eric Voegelin that the biggest problem for today’s Christians wasn’t that they didn’t have the right answers, but that they’d forgotten the question to which they were the answers. // Answers without questions—without the questions that originally provoked them, but also without the subsequent questions that are provoked by every answer—are like trees without roots. But how often are ‘Christian truths’ presented to us like felled, lifeless trees in which birds can no longer find a nest? (As a young professor, Joseph Ratzinger apparently commented, apropos of Jesus’s parable about the kingdom of heaven being like a tree in which birds make their nests, that the Church is beginning dangerously to resemble a tree with many dead branches on which there frequently sit some rather odd birds…). // It takes the confrontation of questions and answers to return a real meaning and dynamic to our statements. Truth happens
in the course of dialogue. There is always a temptation to allow our answers to bring to an end the process of searching, as if the topic of the conversation was a problem
that has now been solved. But when a fresh question arrives, the unexhausted depths of mystery
show through once more. Let it be said over and over again: faith is not a question of problems but of mystery, so we must never abandon the path of seeking and asking. Yes, in seeking Zacchaeus we must often shift from problems to mystery, from apparently final answers back to infinite questions. // Paul, the ‘thirteenth apostle,’ who did the most to spread the Gospel, wrote: ‘I have become all things to all.’ Maybe at this time we will discover Christ’s closeness most effectively if we, His disciples, make ourselves seekers with those who seek
and questioners with those who question. There are more than enough of those who declare they have already reached their goal and offer ready-made but often facile answers, and unfortunately they are also to be found among those who invoke the name of Jesus. Maybe we will make our belief more accessible to the Zacchaeuses of our day if we make them our neighbors, in Jesus’s sense, as they ‘look out through the leaves.’
3. Bible & Fathers: On Patience by St Cyprian
Here' s the opening paragraph to St Cyprian's treatise on patience:
As I am about to speak, beloved brethren, of patience, and to declare its advantages and benefits, from what point should I rather begin than this, that I see that even at this time, for your audience of me, patience is needful, as you cannot even discharge this duty of hearing and learning without patience? For wholesome discourse and reasoning are then effectually learned, if what is said be patiently heard. Nor do I find, beloved brethren, among the rest of the ways of heavenly discipline wherein the path of our hope and faith is directed to the attainment of the divine rewards, anything of more advantage, either as more useful for life or more helpful to glory, than that we who are laboring in the precepts of the Lord with the obedience of fear and devotion, should especially, with our whole watchfulness, be careful of patience.
*If you’d like to receive the Digital Synaxis in your inbox on Wednesdays and Fridays, you can subscribe here.
**All books (and icons) in print available from Eighth Day Books. Please support an independent bookstore that believes in the eighth day resurrection of our God and Lord and Savior Jesus Christ. Give them a call at 1.800.841.2541 or visit their website here. And don’t forget Eighth Day Members (Patrons+) receive 10% discount, plus many other perks! Learn more and become a member here.
